Canada & US Free Shipping When You Spend $100

Canada & US Free Shipping When You Spend $100

Search Login
0 Cart
Search Login
0 Cart
0

Search

NEW

Cara's Story

Our Jewelry

Shop By Name A-K

Shop By Name L-Z

Shop by Type

Bracelets

Charms

Earrings

Necklaces

Rings

Gemstones A-G

Gemstones H-Z

We'll build exactly what you want!

Choose your charm then a necklace or bracelet to create your very own sentimental piece.

Shop now

Choose Your Charm

Choose Your Necklace

Choose Your Bracelet

Shop By Metal

Valentine's Day Edit

Valentine's Day Edit

WE'VE CURATED THE PERFECT SELECTION OF JEWELRY AND ADD-ON GIFTS TO MAKE THE MOST THOUGHTFUL VALENTINE'S DAY.

FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART LOCKET NECKLACE - GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART LOCKET NECKLACE - GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART LOCKET NECKLACE - GOLD Sold Out
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART LOCKET NECKLACE - SILVER - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART LOCKET NECKLACE - SILVER - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART LOCKET NECKLACE - SILVER $157.00 USD
MINI HONOUR SHIELD STUD EARRINGS - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
MINI HONOUR SHIELD STUD EARRINGS - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
MINI HONOUR STUD EARRINGS - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD $88.00 USD
LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - GOLD $53.00 USD
Love Namesake Candle - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
Love Namesake Candle - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
Love Namesake Candle $14.00 USD
Jewelry Dish - Gold Speckled - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
Jewelry Dish - Gold Speckled - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
Jewelry Dish - Gold Speckled $16.00 USD
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STRETCH BRACELET - GOLD 7" - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STRETCH BRACELET - GOLD 7" - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STRETCH BRACELET - GOLD Sold Out
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STUDS - PINK OPAL & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STUDS - PINK OPAL & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STUDS - PINK OPAL & GOLD $96.00 USD
TINY PROTECT STUD EARRINGS - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
TINY PROTECT STUD EARRINGS - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
TINY PROTECT STUD EARRINGS - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD Sold Out
E-Gift Card Sent By Email - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
E-Gift Card Sent By Email - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
E-Gift Card Sent By Email from $18.89 USD
So Pretty "Fused" Permanent Jewelry Appointment - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
So Pretty "Fused" Permanent Jewelry Appointment $16.00 USD
"Fused" E-Gift Card - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
"Fused" E-Gift Card from $37.78 USD
Cute Bum Valentine, Greeting Card - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
Cute Bum Valentine, Greeting Card - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
Cute Bum Valentine, Greeting Card $5.00 USD
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STRETCH BRACELET – PINK OPAL & GOLD 7" - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STRETCH BRACELET – PINK OPAL & GOLD 7" - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STRETCH BRACELET – PINK OPAL & GOLD $132.00 USD
TINY TRIO LOVE STUDS - CUBIC ZIRCONIA & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
TINY TRIO LOVE STUDS - CUBIC ZIRCONIA & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
TINY TRIO LOVE STUDS - CUBIC ZIRCONIA & GOLD Sold Out
PROTECT OVAL RING - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
PROTECT OVAL RING - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
PROTECT OVAL RING - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD $115.00 USD
LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - SILVER - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - SILVER - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - SILVER $53.00 USD
DAINTY LEGACY STUDS - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
DAINTY LEGACY STUDS - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
DAINTY LEGACY STUDS - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD $61.00 USD
LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - ROSE GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - ROSE GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - ROSE GOLD $53.00 USD
LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - HOT PINK CHALCEDONY & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - HOT PINK CHALCEDONY & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - HOT PINK CHALCEDONY $53.00 USD
DAY 6 - Luxe Charming Herringbone Chain 16.5 - 18" Necklace Gold - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
DAY 6 - Luxe Charming Herringbone Chain 16.5 - 18" Necklace Gold - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LUXE FEARLESS HERRINGBONE CHAIN 16.5 - 18" NECKLACE GOLD $124.00 USD
Wanderlust Weekender Jewelry Bag - Blush Pink - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
Wanderlust Weekender Jewelry Bag - Blush Pink - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
Wanderlust Weekender Jewelry Bag - Blush Pink $55.00 USD
Wanderlust Daily Jewelry Bag - Blush Pink - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
Wanderlust Daily Jewelry Bag - Blush Pink - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
Wanderlust Daily Jewelry Bag - Blush Pink $25.00 USD
MINI PROTECT RING PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
MINI PROTECT RING PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
MINI PROTECT RING PINK QUARTZ & GOLD $74.00 USD
PREORDER FRAICHE INSPIRE LOCKET NECKLACE - SILVER - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
PREORDER FRAICHE INSPIRE LOCKET NECKLACE - SILVER - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE LOCKET NECKLACE - SILVER $124.00 USD
FRAICHE INSPIRE LOCKET NECKLACE - ROSE GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE LOCKET NECKLACE - ROSE GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE LOCKET NECKLACE - ROSE GOLD $124.00 USD
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STRETCH BRACELET - SILVER 7" - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STRETCH BRACELET - SILVER 7" - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STRETCH BRACELET - SILVER $132.00 USD
MINI HONOUR SHIELD STUD EARRINGS - PINK OPAL & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
MINI HONOUR SHIELD STUD EARRINGS - PINK OPAL & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
MINI HONOUR STUD EARRINGS - PINK OPAL & GOLD Sold Out
MINI LOVE CIRCLE STUDS - CUBIC ZIRCONIA & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
MINI LOVE CIRCLE STUDS - CUBIC ZIRCONIA & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
MINI LOVE CIRCLE STUDS - CUBIC ZIRCONIA & GOLD $61.00 USD
DAINTY LEGACY STUDS - PINK OPAL & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
DAINTY LEGACY STUDS - PINK OPAL & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
DAINTY LEGACY STUDS - PINK OPAL & GOLD Sold Out
Hello Lover Valentine, Greeting Card - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
Hello Lover Valentine, Greeting Card - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
Hello Lover Valentine, Greeting Card $5.00 USD
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STUDS - PINK OPAL & SILVER - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STUDS - PINK OPAL & SILVER - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STUDS - PINK OPAL & SILVER $96.00 USD
GRACE RING - PINK OPAL & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
GRACE RING - PINK OPAL & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
GRACE RING - PINK OPAL & GOLD $61.00 USD
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STRETCH BRACELET – PINK OPAL & SILVER 7" - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STRETCH BRACELET – PINK OPAL & SILVER 7" - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FRAICHE INSPIRE SWEETHEART STRETCH BRACELET – PINK OPAL & SILVER $132.00 USD
TINY DREAM STARDUST STUDS - HOT PINK CHALCEDONY & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
TINY DREAM STARDUST STUDS - HOT PINK CHALCEDONY & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
TINY DREAM STARDUST STUDS - HOT PINK CHALCEDONY Sold Out
PROTECT PENDANT NECKLACE - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
PROTECT PENDANT NECKLACE - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
PROTECT PENDANT NECKLACE - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD $115.00 USD
LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - LAPIS & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - LAPIS & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - LAPIS & GOLD $53.00 USD
ICONIC LONG BEADED NECKLACE - PINK OPAL & GOLD 34" - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
ICONIC LONG BEADED NECKLACE - PINK OPAL & GOLD 34" - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
ICONIC LONG BEADED NECKLACE - PINK OPAL & GOLD 34" $150.00 USD
GLEE RING - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
GLEE RING - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
GLEE RING - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD $88.00 USD
JOY STUDS - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
JOY STUDS - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
JOY STUDS - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD Sold Out
LOYAL RING PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOYAL RING PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOYAL RING PINK QUARTZ & GOLD $74.00 USD
ICONIC SHORT BEADED NECKLACE - PINK OPAL & GOLD 16-20" - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
ICONIC SHORT BEADED NECKLACE - PINK OPAL & GOLD 16-20" - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
ICONIC SHORT BEADED NECKLACE - PINK OPAL & GOLD 16-20" $75.00 USD
LOVE TENNIS NECKLACE - CUBIC ZIRCONIA & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOVE TENNIS NECKLACE - CUBIC ZIRCONIA & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOVE TENNIS NECKLACE - CUBIC ZIRCONIA & GOLD $149.00 USD
MINI LOVE CIRCLE STUDS - CUBIC ZIRCONIA & SILVER - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
MINI LOVE CIRCLE STUDS - CUBIC ZIRCONIA & SILVER - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
MINI LOVE CIRCLE STUDS - CUBIC ZIRCONIA & SILVER Sold Out
DAINTY LEGACY NECKLACE - PINK OPAL & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
DAINTY LEGACY NECKLACE - PINK OPAL & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
DAINTY LEGACY NECKLACE - PINK OPAL & GOLD $88.00 USD
PROTECT OVAL RING - PINK OPAL & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
PROTECT OVAL RING - PINK OPAL & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
PROTECT OVAL RING - PINK OPAL & GOLD $115.00 USD
LOYAL STUD EARRINGS - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOYAL STUD EARRINGS - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOYAL STUD EARRINGS - PINK QUARTZ & GOLD $61.00 USD
LOVE SOLITAIRE STUDS - GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOVE SOLITAIRE STUDS - GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOVE SOLITAIRE STUDS - GOLD & CUBIC ZIRCONIA Sold Out
LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - DIAMONDS & SOLID 14K GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - DIAMONDS & SOLID 14K GOLD - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
14K SOLID GOLD - LOVE THIN DISK BAND RING - DIAMONDS $329.00 USD
Fearless Namesake Candle - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
Fearless Namesake Candle - SO PRETTY CARA COTTER
FEARLESS NAMESAKE CANDLE $14.00 USD
Load More Products